thomistica
  • Home
  • News
  • Posts
  • Essays
  • Book Reviews
  • Texts and Links St. Thomas' Last Days Pictures Duane Berquist Audio Commentary on Prima Pars, Part One Commentary on Prima Pars, q.3 Commentary on 1a, qq. 3-7 Commentary, qq. 8-10 Commentary, 1a q. 11 - q. 12 a. 5 SCG Title SCG Intro
  • SUBMIT
  • Contact
thomistica
  • Home/
  • News/
  • Posts/
  • Essays/
  • Book Reviews/
  • Other/
    • Texts and Links
    • St. Thomas' Last Days
    • Pictures
    • Duane Berquist Audio Commentary on Prima Pars, Part One
    • Commentary on Prima Pars, q.3
    • Commentary on 1a, qq. 3-7
    • Commentary, qq. 8-10
    • Commentary, 1a q. 11 - q. 12 a. 5
    • SCG Title
    • SCG Intro
  • SUBMIT/
  • Contact/
gettyimages-700192393-1024x1024ghb.png
thomistica

A SITE DEVOTED TO THE ACADEMIC STUDY OF SAINT THOMAS AQUINAS, SPONSORED BY THE SACRA DOCTRINA PROJECT

Essays

thomistica
  • Home/
  • News/
  • Posts/
  • Essays/
  • Book Reviews/
  • Other/
    • Texts and Links
    • St. Thomas' Last Days
    • Pictures
    • Duane Berquist Audio Commentary on Prima Pars, Part One
    • Commentary on Prima Pars, q.3
    • Commentary on 1a, qq. 3-7
    • Commentary, qq. 8-10
    • Commentary, 1a q. 11 - q. 12 a. 5
    • SCG Title
    • SCG Intro
  • SUBMIT/
  • Contact/

Essays

This section is devoted to essays on Thomistic theology, philosophy, scholarship, and topics related thereto.

April 29, 2020

The Psychological Possibility of Mortal Sin: A Reply to Hart

April 29, 2020/ Ryan J Brady
The Psychological Possibility of Mortal Sin: A Reply to Hart

By WILLIAM MATTHEW DIEM, S.T.D.

Although David Bentley Hart admits we can reject God, he insists that “we cannot do so with perfect knowledge and perfect freedom.” Although it’s true that no sane person is able to choose eternal misery as such, that is not relevant to the question: one need not choose misery to merit misery.

Read More
April 29, 2020/ Ryan J Brady/ 3 Comments
April 27, 2020

Thomas Aquinas Against the Originalists

April 27, 2020/ Matthew Dugandzic
Thomas Aquinas Against the Originalists

By JONATHAN CULBREATH

As opposed to the originalist conception of law, St. Thomas teaches that law is an ordinance of reason for the common good promulgated by him who has power over the community, derived from the natural law itself, for the purpose of making men virtuous.

Read More
April 27, 2020/ Matthew Dugandzic/ Comment
Political Theory
Thomas Aquinas, Law, Common Good
December 01, 2019

Those Two Roads: How a Natural Philosophical Solution to a Difficulty about Motion Serves Thomistic Theology

December 01, 2019/ Ryan J Brady
Those Two Roads: How a Natural Philosophical Solution to a Difficulty about Motion Serves Thomistic Theology

By JOHN BRUNGARDT, Ph.D.

A consideration of the philosophical notion of motion and how this aids Thomistic theology.

Read More
December 01, 2019/ Ryan J Brady/ Comment
July 14, 2019

Three Divine Persons Distinguished by Four Real Relations: On the Correct Translation of ST I, Q. 30, A. 2

July 14, 2019/ Ryan J Brady
Three Divine Persons Distinguished by  Four Real Relations: On the Correct Translation of ST I, Q. 30, A. 2

JOHN O’NEILL, PhD Cand.

Thomas has already identified four relations in God and defined a divine person as a subsisting relation. Why, then, are the four real relations not four persons? Or why are there not only three real relations that subsist?

Read More
July 14, 2019/ Ryan J Brady/ Comment
July 05, 2019

The Importance of Good Posture

July 05, 2019/ Taylor O'Neill
The Importance of Good Posture

BRETT T. FEGER

Aquinas’ analysis of the physical disposition of man’s posture provides a groundwork from which a meaningful conversation can be had with evolutionary materialists who reduce man to a mere animal.

Read More
July 05, 2019/ Taylor O'Neill/ Comment
March 01, 2019

Marriage: The Greatest of Friendship

March 01, 2019/ Joshua Madden
Marriage: The Greatest of Friendship

JOSHUA MADDEN, PhD

Put briefly, we can say along with Thomas Aquinas that “between husband and wife, it seems, there exists the greatest of friendship.”

Read More
March 01, 2019/ Joshua Madden/ 2 Comments
February 20, 2019

Some Mistakes Due to What is Per Accidens

February 20, 2019/ Taylor O'Neill
Some Mistakes Due to What is Per Accidens

JOHN G. BRUNGARDT, PhD

Against some important philosophical mistakes which occur by the conflation of what is per accidens with what is per se.

Read More
February 20, 2019/ Taylor O'Neill/ Comment
February 01, 2019

St. Thomas Aquinas for Beginners

February 01, 2019/ Taylor O'Neill
St. Thomas Aquinas for Beginners

DAVID A. SMITHER

A very brief introduction to the life and work of St. Thomas Aquinas.

Read More
February 01, 2019/ Taylor O'Neill/ Comment
December 21, 2018

Subordinated Causality as Illustration of Philosophy's Service to Theology

December 21, 2018/ Taylor O'Neill
Subordinated Causality as Illustration of Philosophy's Service to Theology

TAYLOR PATRICK O’NEILL, PhD

There is a plethora of examples of the service which philosophy provides to theology. Perhaps one of the best examples is that of subordinated causality.

Read More
December 21, 2018/ Taylor O'Neill/ 1 Comment
December 10, 2018

What is a Thomist? The Contribution of John of St. Thomas

December 10, 2018/ Taylor O'Neill
What is a Thomist? The Contribution of John of St. Thomas

JÖRGEN VIJGEN, PhD

What accounts for the essence and unity of Thomism? Two approaches have been developed: a doctrinal approach and a methodological approach, but a third approach has been developed by John of St. Thomas.

Read More
December 10, 2018/ Taylor O'Neill/ Comment
November 14, 2018

Aquinas on Name in Sacramental Formulae

November 14, 2018/ Taylor O'Neill
Aquinas on Name in Sacramental Formulae

BRANDON L. WANLESS, PhD (cand.)

Aquinas provides the theological ratio underpinning the words of the sacramental formulae, namely, of baptizing, confirming, and absolving precisely “in the name of” the Trinity.

Read More
November 14, 2018/ Taylor O'Neill/ 1 Comment
November 09, 2018

A Thomistic Critique of Cartesian Dualism

November 09, 2018/ Taylor O'Neill
A Thomistic Critique of Cartesian Dualism

PAUL CHUTIKORN

Aquinas’ view of substance provides a solution to Descartes’ problem by avoiding a theory of dual substances. Aquinas shows us that we can acknowledge a duality within substance itself, while maintaining its inherent substantial unity.

Read More
November 09, 2018/ Taylor O'Neill/ Comment
October 07, 2018

Aquinas' View of Israel in the Isaiah Commentary

October 07, 2018/ Joshua Madden
Aquinas' View of Israel in the Isaiah Commentary

JOSHUA MADDEN, PhD

As the commentary on Isaiah is one of the few which St. Thomas composed on the Old Testament, it is worth taking stock of the manner in which he speaks specifically of Israel and the Jews, even if only briefly.

Read More
October 07, 2018/ Joshua Madden/ Comment
October 03, 2018

MORAL PRECEPTS OF THE OLD LAW

October 03, 2018/ Ryan J Brady
MORAL PRECEPTS OF THE OLD LAW

RYAN J. BRADY, PhD

The New Law, which is perfect, supplies what was lacking in it. Both are directed to man’s justification, but the Old Law did not provide the means for its fulfillment as the New Law does.

Read More
October 03, 2018/ Ryan J Brady/ Comment
  • Previous
  • Essays

Under the direction of the Sacra Doctrina Project